A Classic Homemade Eggnog Recipe

Written by Elizabeth Nyland of Guilty Kitchen.

Fresh farm eggs: there’s nothing quite like them. What they offer more than anything else though, is food safety. Knowing where your eggs come from, what the chickens eat and how they live offers you great insight into their health status. Plus, the quality of farm fresh eggs just can’t be beat, and are a dream to work with, as my homemade mayonnaise demonstrates so well.

Eating raw eggs can be dangerous as they can become contaminated with salmonella and you would never know it. Mostly this is dangerous for immune compromised people, such as young children and the elderly or ill, but they can be dangerous for anyone.

Having fresher-than-fresh eggs that come from your own backyard chickens can reduce the risk of contamination as you are the one who has handled them from nest to kitchen, but it does not eliminate the possibility of contamination, it merely reduces the risk.

Not everyone has the opportunity to keep chickens, but it is easy to buy farm fresh eggs from roadside stands. An even better method would be to talk to the farmer and find out just how fresh those eggs are. Read more on ways to procure local fresh foods here.


All photos by Elizabeth Nyland

When making recipes that call for raw eggs, such as the eggnog recipe below, be sure to use the freshest eggs possible. Wash the shells before cracking to ensure nothing gets into the egg once they are removed from the shell.

Holiday Eggnog

Having eggnog during the holidays has become a tradition dating back to when I was in high school. The first time I tried, I made four quarts and the only ones drinking it were my father and me. Good thing we liked it so much. Ever since then I’ve tried to make it every year when we have people over.

This recipe is more than simple to make and keeps well as there is alcohol present (caution: don’t save it for more than a couple of days without alcohol).

Try this recipe out and make eggnog an annual tradition in your house! We find it pairs beautifully with Pumpkin Chiffon Pie, but you can be the judge of that!


Classic Eggnog
Print

Recipe type: Drinks
Author:
Prep time:
Total time:
Serves/Yield: 1 1/2 quart
Ingredients
  • 5 egg yolks
  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 1 cup heavy cream
  • 2 cups whole milk
  • 1 1/4 cups good quality bourbon or whiskey
  • 1/4 cup spiced rum
  • Pinch of salt
  • 1 tsp vanilla
  • 1/2 tsp nutmeg plus more for garnish
Instructions
  1. Whisk yolks with sugar until creamy and sugar begins to dissolve.
  2. Add cream, milk, bourbon and rum and stir to combine.
  3. Stir in nutmeg and vanilla and chill well.
  4. Serve chilled on the rocks with a sprinkle of nutmeg if desired.
Notes
Variation 1: Include the egg whites
I don’t use the egg whites, but it is the traditional way. To use the whites, reserve 1/4 cup of the sugar. Beat egg whites to soft peaks and then beat in sugar until stiff peaks form. In a separate bowl, beat 1/2 cup heavy cream. Fold egg whites into cream and serve on top of eggnog with a sprinkle of nutmeg.
Variation 2: Cook the eggs
Making a danger-free eggnog is pretty easy too. Simply follow the same recipe above, but leave out the alcohol and mix only half the milk and cream into the blend, then heat the mixture in a glass or metal bowl over a pot of simmering water for about five or six minutes. Be sure to stir constantly. Refrigerate until well chilled.

When ready to serve, simply stir in the remaining cream and milk, as well as the bourbon and rum.
Variation 3: Virgin Eggnog
Follow the recipe as directed, omitting the alcohol and adding an extra 3/4 cup of whole milk, 3/4 cup of cream and 1-2 tablespoons of rum extract to the mix. Chill and serve.

 

What’s your traditional Holiday drink?

About Elizabeth

On her blog, Guilty Kitchen, Elizabeth writes about the joys of local food, buying sustainable and feeling much too guilty after indulging in too many rich desserts.

Subscribe For Free!

Like reading this post?
Get more delivered to your email inbox.

Comments

  1. These pics are absolutely stunning… they make me totally want to give Eggnog another chance!!!
    Amanda’s last post: How To Bake A Level Cake

  2. This looks so rich and yummy!!

    I usually drink egg nog without alcohol in it. I am thinking that is a serious mistake. I want this kind. With rum and bourbon in it!!
    Cookbook Queen’s last post: Pecan Pie Trifles

  3. Yum! I love eggnog but have never made it – this will be my first year attempting it. Thanks for a wonderful recipe.

    I totally agree with you regarding eggs – I have dreams of having chickens in my backyard giving me eggs, but until then we actually go to a local farm, where my son gets to pick which eggs we take home! I’ll be using some of those for your eggnog :)
    Jennifer’s last post: A Stress-free Holiday Meal – Step 1- Create a Menu

  4. I’ve never had eggnog and I think I may try the cooked version! We don’t have a traditional drink around here…but usually the 21+ people have a beer or a glass of wine with Christmas dinner.

  5. I have never had eggnog but I think this year might be the year! this recipe looks delicious!
    Lisa’s last post: Eco Friendly Ways to Freshen Up the Fabric in Your Home

  6. Great article Elizabeth! The egg nog was just great too!

  7. Aunt Anne says:

    Hi Liz, great recipe and my absolute favorite at this time of year. Am loving your pics as well!

  8. Steph (The Cheapskate Cook) says:

    Only egg nog I ever tried was virgin from the carton. And I don’t even remember what I thought about it – yes, I’m posoitive it was VIRGIN….
    Your recipe sounds like a great one to give it another go!

    Fav holiday drink right now… peppermint mocha latte
    Steph (The Cheapskate Cook)’s last post: Ask the Readers- How to Spice Up Mush

  9. I don’t really like eggnog, but I’m almost convinced to give it a try! Your homemade version sounds so much better than the store bought ones I’ve tasted over the years.

  10. I’m planning on either making this eggnog or possibly just buying a bottle of PA Dutch eggnog and bringing it to my parents’ house for Christmas.

    Last year, my gift to our extended families was a box of peppermint tea and a box of hot chocolate (for peppermint hot chocolate), along with a cute mug (only 5 cents from the thrift store!) and a hand-knit mug cozy. They were a big hit!

  11. I’ve had real and had store bought but this year I’m on a quest for a truly tasty vegan egg nog for my daughter who’s gone vegan. I’m not sure I’ll find a recipe I like so I may create it myself. I don’t really think I want tofu in it. :)
    Alicia’s last post: Rude email leads to positive change on GMOs at snack food company

  12. I always have just one glass of eggnog each season, then I’m done. Making it sounds like such a good idea!
    Kristen’s last post: Cookie Trends Recipe- Cinnamon Roll Cookies with Vanilla Glaze

  13. Just picked up ingredients to make a big batch of the eggnog at my holiday cookie swap!! Can’t wait!

  14. mmmhealthyfoodie says:

    I particularly love eggnog during the holiday season. In fact, I wish they sold it more after, but its just like most products, there is a season or time for everything, Anyways, I was going to make a quick suggestion, I use pasteurized eggs when I make eggnog at home. I mean I use them for all of my cooking needs, especially cookies, (so I can eat the dough and not worry.) But I have been following the new food safety bill and the news about the recent egg recalls , and no never can be completely positive that what you are eating is safe and good for you. I know with pasteurized eggs, I won’t have to worry when I’m sipping on my homemade eggnog. Check them out, I think they can be one of your alternatives.

    Thanks,

    Happy Holidays

  15. I’m not a an egg nog drinker but my hubs is huge on it, so I’m going to surprise him with this.

    • That’s so fun, Naomi! I can’t stand the store bought stuff – it tastes like syrup. But homemade eggnog is magical! You may surprise yourself.

  16. There is just no comparison between homemade and store bought eggnog – once you’ve had homemade you just can’t go back!! So those who don’t think they like eggnog, try this one and I will bet you will be a convert!!

    Elizabeth – excellent points about eggs and food safety!!!

  17. Quick question, if we make the cooked version and also want it to be alcohol free, do we add the second half of the milk/cream and then the additional 3/4 cups of milk and cream later (when we add the extract)? So the recipe would have 1 3/4 cups cream and 1 3/4 cups whole milk total?

  18. Whoops, I meant 1 3/4 cream and 2 3/4 whole milk. Right?

  19. Hello Torey,

    To make the cooked version alcohol free, I would mix up all the milk and cream, pour half into the bowl to cook the yolk sin and then finish with the other half at the end. So yes, you would have 1 3/4 cups cream and 2 3/4 cups whole milk. Add the extract at the end though, after cooking!
    Elizabeth’s last post: Christmas Baking- Roundup

    • Thanks for the help. My daughter is very excited about making this, as I have had to tell her “no, we can’t buy egg nog at the store b/c it is full of HF corn syrup” over, and over again.

  20. Mary unruh says:

    I made this for a brunch today with several international friends….BIG HIT! Thanks, for the several versions to choose from…..I made the cooked (even though I trust my backyard hens) w/ alcohol. Several had never tried eggnog and were skeptical at first but it caught on fast :) I liked that it had great flavor without the three fifths of booze my fathers 19th century recipe has! (in that one you beat the whites and fold them back into the eggnog. 2doz eggs and a couple quarts of cream later and zzzzzzz!)

  21. Definitely try this Vegan version when you get a chance!

    http://www.fourgreensteps.com/community/recipes/60/327

  22. Hello,
    Thank you so much for the great recipe. I made it tonight on Christmas Eve and it was a huge hit. I used store eggs and did not cook them so lets hope everyone doesn’t get sick tomorrow.

    Great share, take care and have a marry Christmas!

    • Well it has been a year and I am not revisiting this recipe. This is some really excellent eggnog. I have found it easier for people if I just don’t tell them that there are raw eggs in it.

      Thanks again!

      (By the way, no one got sick last year at Christmas, or any other time I have made this.)

  23. I’m from South Africa and the first time that I’ve heard about eggnog was on the soapy Days of our lifes. I will certainly make some. My father used to make his own creamy ice cream drink with milk,rum and vanilla ice cream. Thanx!

  24. Thank you for this article. We made egg nog from our own backyard eggs. It is so delicious! I included a link to this recipe/article. =]
    Driz’s last post: We Brock You a Merry Christmas

  25. Thank you Driz!
    Elizabeth’s last post: Cookies for Santa: Classic Peanut Butter

  26. How does the egg nog differ when you add the egg whites in stead of the traditional version?

  27. never made eggnog before… just made it with my son and his girlfriend… the uncooked variation and it is THE BEST WE HAVE EVER HAD. hands down better than anything in the store. thanks for the recipe!!

  28. I have my own little ladies that provide me daily with beautiful eggs. A farm fresh egg has no comparison to store bought. Farm fresh are full flavour and colourful. I love egg nog but I Find it so sweet that I weaken it with milk. So excited to try this recipe!

  29. Excellent eggnog. We made the alcohol free version. My husband loved it and he is an eggnog connoisseur!

Speak Your Mind

*

Rate this recipe:  

CommentLuv badge